Despite Carson’s intentions, her advice has met strong criticism. Some argue that asking a baby for consent before a diaper change is unnecessary, impractical, or even absurd. Critics like Rowan Dean, editor of The Spectator Australia, labeled it “lefty lunacy,” while parenting columnist John Rosemond dismissed the approach as confusing and potentially harmful to family dynamics.
On social media, reactions ranged from humor to disbelief. Users joked about seeking a cat’s permission before cleaning its litter box or noted that a crying infant already communicates a need clearly. Others questioned whether Carson’s ideas are grounded in the realities of everyday parenting.
Yet not all responses were negative. Supporters acknowledged that while the example might be symbolic, the principle behind it—teaching respect, communication, and awareness of others’ signals—is valuable. They highlighted that infants and toddlers communicate in nuanced ways long before they speak and that recognizing these cues can foster emotional development and trust. Carson’s ideas, they argue, encourage parents to engage intentionally with their children rather than simply perform routine tasks.
Importantly, the approach does not mean neglecting a baby’s immediate needs. Caregivers must still respond promptly to health and comfort requirements. The goal is to add a mindful layer of respect, helping infants feel seen and heard from day one.
The conversation around Carson’s suggestion reflects broader shifts in parenting philosophies, balancing tradition with modern ideas about autonomy, respect, and communication. While some view asking for consent as a progressive tool for empowering children, others see it as an impractical ideal. Ultimately, the choice to integrate consent language into infant care is personal, influenced by cultural, familial, and philosophical beliefs.
This debate reminds us of the diversity of parenting approaches today and challenges caregivers to reflect on how they teach respect, trust, and communication from the earliest stages of life.
